County Moves forward on Unlimited Density for Hotels on Siesta Key

December 2, 2023 —

Despite significant public opposition, County Commissioners voted 3-1 to advance only Benderson ‘s proposal for unlimited density for hotels on Siesta Key at their November 28 meeting. Commissioner Smith requested that all three proposals be forwarded for comparison and study, however, Commissioner Moran did not support the amendment. Commissioner Smith was the lone no vote.

The Siesta Key Association (SKA), Siesta Key Condominium Council, Siesta Key Coalition, Pine Shores Neighborhood Alliance, and many Siesta residents spoke in opposition, warning that advancing any of the proposals would significantly strain the Key’s infrastructure.

To view the video of the November 28 meeting, select this link. Scroll down to “Open to the Public” to view public testimony. Scroll to Item #37 to view Commission discussion.

The next step in the process for the public will be a neighborhood workshop. SKA will post further details as they become available.

Herald-Tribune, November 30, 2023, Derek Gilliam: ” County to pursue aggressive growth”

Sarasota News Leader, December 1, 2023; Rachel Brown Hackney: “Commissioner Moran makes motion to direct county staff to process Benderson policy proposals that would allow for high-rise hotels on Siesta Key”

Sarasota/Siesta Key Observer, November 30, 2023, Andrew Warfield: “Another hotel fight brews on Siesta Key”

November 24, 2023 — At their November 28 meeting, County Commissioners will consider three proposals to change development regulations for Siesta Key commercial property. At least one of the proposals could allow building high-density hotels on the Key, similar to hotels that were recently ruled illegal in two court cases.  As usual, the meeting begins at 9 am in the Commission Chambers, 1660 Ringling Blvd.

Developers are requesting that their three proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendments be processed in advance of the normal annual cycle. The staff memo states, “The Board may choose to authorize all three, or one, or none of the amendments to move forward for review and consideration.”

To read the 3 proposals, follow this link and select the November 28 meeting “Agenda“. Scroll down and select Item #37. Use the same link to view the meeting live. To provide input prior to the meeting, email This is not a public hearing, so live comments will only be allowed during the 9amOpen to the Public” section at the start of the meeting. 

Sarasota News Leader, November 24, 2023; Rachel Brown Hackney: “Will politics prevail during Nov. 28 County Commission discussion of policies that would allow high-rise hotels on Siesta Key?”